jump to navigation

‘A Great Victory’: Controversial Brazilian Dam Construction Halted August 15, 2012

Posted by rogerhollander in Brazil, Energy, Environment, First Nations, Latin America.
Tags: , , , , , , , , ,
Published on Wednesday, August 15, 2012 by Common Dreams


Brazilian Federal court finds Belo Monte hydro-electric dam licenses invalid, indigenous peoples were not consulted

– Common Dreams staff

(photo: International Rivers via Flickr)

A victory came to activists in Brazil on Tuesday when a federal judge halted construction on the controversial Belo Monte dam in the Amazon, saying that the indigenous peoples had not been consulted.

The impacts of the dam, which would have been the third largest hydro-electric dam in the world, had long been slammed by indigenous groups and environmental activists who said that it would have displaced thousands and wreaked havoc upon the ecosystem while contributing to greenhouse gases.

When the Brazilian Congress gave approval for the dam in 2005, there were no consultations with the indigenous peoples about the environmental impacts, a fact that Judge Souza Prudente found in violation of the Brazilian Constitution.

“A study on the environmental impact of the project was required before, not after, work on the dam started. The legislation is flawed,” Judge Souza Prudente told O Globo newspaper.

“The Brazilian Congress must take into account the decisions taken by the indigenous communities. Legislators can only give the go-ahead if the indigenous communities agree with the project,” he said.

Souza Prudente remarked at a press conference that “only in a dictatorial regime does a government approve a project before holding consultations.”

Indigenous groups lauded the court ruling. “It’s a historic decision for the country and for the native communities,” said Antonia Melo, coordinator of the Xingu Vivo indigenous movement.

“It’s a great victory which shows that Belo Monte is not a done deal. We are very happy and satisfied.”

Zachary Hurwitz of International Rivers writes that “the decision supports the arguments that the affected tribes have been making over the lifetime of Belo Monte: tribes will face downstream livelihood impacts as a result of a reduction in the flow of the Xingu River on the 100-km stretch known as the Volta Grande or ‘Big Bend,’ and were never properly consulted, much less gave their consent.”

Hurwitz adds that the economic rationale dam proponents pushed is fundamentally flawed. “Economic rationale for the dam is based on a projected economic growth of 5% or more a year, but over the past few quarters, GDP has been lucky to grow at even a measly rate. As far as Belo Monte’s importance to Brazil’s economic race, this is really a case of the horse following the wagon.”

“And, as illustrated by this historic court decision, the wagon has been trampling on indigenous people and their rights, along the way,” writes Hurwitz.

Showing 4 comments

  • webwalk 1 comment collapsed CollapseExpand

    Brave act by Judge Souza Prudente. And praise to the International Rivers organization for their relentless solidarity work.

    Now we need to flip the economy and replace the neoliberal capitalist system with an Earth-centered and people-centered economy, so that victories like this are not isolated and temporary!

    show more show less


  • future4the 1 comment collapsed CollapseExpand

    Congratulations to the judge and the people of Brazil who are standing up for the rights of our earth and all living creatures.

    show more show less


  • julea bacall 1 comment collapsed CollapseExpand

    Finally some really good news!! More even than the stopping of the dam construction is the fact that Leaders in Power listened to the People! This should be broadcasted all over the world as a model for all Presidents,dictators and Leaders!

    Peace can only follow Justice.

    show more show less


  • Chris Randolph 1 comment collapsed CollapseExpand

    “At the site of the protest, visited by Al Jazeera on Wednesday, the
    tribesmen were carrying clubs and spears and had built rudimentary
    sleeping quarters in what has essentially become a non-violent sit-in.”

    It’s amazing how clubs and spears can keep an occupation from being beaten by police. Will there be any anti-Black Bloc comments about how the locals were ruining Occupy Brazil with their macho terror tactics..?

    show more show less



No comments yet — be the first.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: